
Energy performance contracts and savings guarantees, explained
An energy performance contract links what you pay for an energy upgrade to the savings it actually delivers. If the savings fall short, the contractor makes up the difference. The catch is that a guarantee is only worth what the measurement behind it is worth.
By Rachel McKeogh, Operations Support Manager at VisionGreen. Updated .
What an energy performance contract is
An energy performance contract (EPC) is an agreement where an energy services company designs and delivers energy saving measures and guarantees a level of savings, measured against a baseline agreed before the work starts. The contractor is paid from the savings that arise. If the savings fall short of the guarantee, the contractor covers the difference. The contract can run for several years, with the savings guaranteed every year.
SEAI's own guidance treats a full EPC as the strongest form of guarantee and says it usually suits projects over €350,000 that combine several energy saving measures. For smaller projects there are two lighter forms of the same idea, covered next.
The three pay-for-performance models used in Ireland
SEAI's Energy Contracting Support Scheme recognises three mechanisms. They differ in who funds the work, how long the guarantee runs and how much paperwork is involved.
| Model | How it works | Who funds the work | Typical use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Energy performance guarantee (EPG) | The vendor supplies the upgrade and guarantees the savings. If they fall short, the vendor loses part or all of a performance payment | Usually the client, with leasing or payment plans linked to savings as an option | Single measures or small packages: lighting, controls, refrigeration, heat recovery |
| Energy performance contract (EPC) | A stronger guarantee over several years. The vendor is paid from the savings and covers any shortfall every year | Client or vendor | Projects over about €350,000 with several measures, such as heat pumps plus controls plus fabric |
| Local energy supply contract (LESC) or PPA | A vendor installs a generator, such as solar PV or CHP, and sells you the energy it produces at an agreed price for a number of years | Vendor | On-site generation where you would rather buy the output than own the plant |
Guaranteed savings and shared savings
Within an EPC, two payment structures are common.
- Guaranteed savings: you fund the project, often with a loan or grant. The contractor guarantees that measured savings will reach a set figure each year. Any shortfall is paid to you by the contractor. You keep everything above the guarantee.
- Shared savings: the contractor funds some or all of the project and is paid an agreed share of the measured savings over the contract term. You carry less capital risk and keep a smaller share of the saving until the term ends.
A worked example
The figures below are illustrative, to show how the pieces fit. A 120-bedroom hotel spends €420,000 a year on energy. An audit and six months of circuit-level monitoring identify three measures: BMS optimisation and new controls, heat recovery on the kitchen extract, and a full LED and lighting-control upgrade. Capital cost after SEAI grants: €310,000.
The contractor guarantees savings of €78,000 a year, about 19 per cent of the bill, for seven years. The baseline is the twelve months of metered data before the works, adjusted for occupancy and outside temperature. Savings are measured on the same sub-meters after the works (IPMVP Option B), reported quarterly.
Year one, measured savings come in at €91,000. The hotel keeps the extra €13,000. In year three a mild winter and lower occupancy would have cut the saving to €64,000, but the baseline adjustment for weather and occupancy brings the measured figure to €81,000, above the guarantee, so nothing changes hands. If the adjusted figure had been €70,000, the contractor would have paid the hotel the €8,000 shortfall.
The point of the example is the baseline and the adjustment rules. Without sub-metering and agreed adjustment factors, every one of those numbers would be an argument.
How savings are measured and verified
SEAI requires a measurement and verification (M&V) plan for every grant-funded project, written in line with the International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) or an equivalent such as ISO 50015. The same protocol is what makes a guarantee enforceable. There are four options.
| Option | What is measured | Suits |
|---|---|---|
| A: retrofit isolation, key parameter | One or two key parameters on the affected equipment are measured, the rest are agreed estimates | Simple measures with predictable hours, such as lighting |
| B: retrofit isolation, all parameters | Everything that drives the saving is measured on the affected equipment, usually with sub-meters | Controls, refrigeration, heat recovery, motors, anything with a guarantee attached |
| C: whole facility | The utility meter for the whole site, adjusted for weather, occupancy or production | Large multi-measure projects where the saving is a big share of the total bill |
| D: calibrated simulation | A computer model of the building calibrated to real bills | New builds and deep retrofits where there is no usable baseline |
What SEAI pays towards
The Energy Contracting Support Scheme (ECSS) funds the work of getting a pay-for-performance project to contract: the project energy audit and opportunity evaluation, temporary metering, project facilitation and the external specialist costs of detailed appraisal and procurement. It does not pay for the works themselves; those go through the capital grants such as EXEED or the Business Energy Upgrade Scheme.
Support is up to 75 per cent of eligible costs, capped at €50,000 for an EPC or LESC and €25,000 for an energy performance guarantee. SEAI's guidance describes the typical scale as projects saving more than €50,000 a year at facilities spending more than €250,000 a year on energy, and since late 2023 applicants must appoint a certified, registered EPC Facilitator for the grant-aided work. Public and private sector organisations are both eligible.
When a guarantee is worth asking for
A guarantee makes sense when the project is large enough that a shortfall would hurt, when the savings depend on how equipment is operated rather than just on what is installed, and when the building has a long-term owner or occupier who will still be there in year five. Controls, refrigeration and heat recovery are the classic cases.
For a single measure on a smaller site, a grant-funded project with monitoring before and after usually gives the same certainty with far less paperwork. You still get the measured result; you just do not need a seven-year contract to see it.
Questions to ask any contractor offering a guarantee
- What is the baseline, over what period, and what data is it built on?
- Which IPMVP option, and which meters will do the measuring?
- What are the adjustment factors for weather, occupancy or production, and who calculates them?
- How often are savings reported, and who checks the report?
- What exactly happens, and by when, if the savings fall short?
- What happens if we change how the building is used?
How VisionGreen works
We measure the baseline with circuit-level monitoring before anything is specified, agree a savings guarantee with each client based on that data, and verify the result with the same meters afterwards. For larger projects we set the M&V plan out in the IPMVP format SEAI expects, so the guarantee and the grant paperwork rest on the same numbers.
Sources
Related guides
Common questions
What is an energy performance contract?
An agreement where an energy services company delivers energy saving measures and guarantees the savings, measured against an agreed baseline, usually over several years. The contractor is paid from the savings and covers any shortfall. SEAI's guidance says a full EPC usually suits projects over €350,000 with several measures.
What is an energy performance guarantee?
A lighter version of the same idea for single measures or small packages. The vendor supplies the upgrade and guarantees the saving; if it falls short, the vendor loses part or all of a performance payment. No bespoke contract is usually needed and the client typically funds the work.
What is the difference between guaranteed savings and shared savings?
With guaranteed savings, the client funds the project and the contractor guarantees the savings level, paying any shortfall. With shared savings, the contractor funds some or all of it and is paid an agreed share of the measured savings over the contract term.
How are savings measured in an energy performance contract?
Under an M&V plan written to IPMVP or an equivalent protocol. Most guarantees use Option B: sub-meters on the affected equipment before and after the works, with the baseline adjusted for weather, occupancy or production. SEAI requires an M&V plan on every grant-funded project.
Does SEAI fund energy performance contracts?
SEAI's Energy Contracting Support Scheme pays up to 75 per cent of the cost of appraising and procuring a pay-for-performance project, capped at €50,000 for an EPC or local energy supply contract and €25,000 for an energy performance guarantee. The works themselves are funded through the capital grants.
Does VisionGreen offer a savings guarantee?
Yes. We agree a savings guarantee per client, based on measured data from the site, and verify it with the same monitoring that set the baseline.
Want this applied to your building?
Start with an energy audit. If you spend over ten thousand euro a year on energy, the SEAI grant covers most of the cost.